We live in a world full of stressors. We sit too much and walk too little, and most people use cars for minor things. And don’t forget we worry too much, and all those things can make us more tense and stressed. This is where walking comes in to help solve the issue. Surely, walking and forest bathing are great ways to relax and reduce our stress. So today we are going to explore more about walking versus forest bathing in reducing stress. To be fully clear, some studies are about walking in natural settings, like forests. Not all studies can be called research about forest bathing. Let’s explore this topic with the research we have around this topic!

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases
Forest bathing and walking get compared constantly, and the comparison sounds simple: one is a stroll among trees, the other is a stroll. In the research, the two differ in several ways at once, which makes it hard to say what produces any benefit. This article looks at what studies have compared, what they measured, where the evidence is weak, and how you can run your own comparison. If you want the biology of how time among trees may lower cortisol, that is covered in the forest bathing and cortisol article; this piece takes up the narrower question of forest bathing vs walking for stress.
Why comparing forest bathing and a walk is harder than it sounds
A fair comparison changes one thing and holds everything else constant. Forest bathing and a regular walk differ in at least four things: the setting, the pace, the amount of physical effort, and where your attention goes. A study that sends one group to a forest and another through a city street changes the setting, but the forest group may also have walked more slowly, breathed less exhaust, and heard less noise.
Researchers do try to control some of this. Common designs have the same participants visit a forest on one day and an urban area on another, with similar walking distances. That removes differences between people, which helps. It does not separate the trees from the quiet, the cleaner air, the softer ground, or the fact that a trip to a forest feels like an occasion.
There is also the question of what counts as a “regular walk.” A brisk lunchtime loop past traffic and a slow evening wander through a park are both walks, yet they may affect your body very differently. When a headline says forest bathing beats walking, the result depends heavily on which kind of walk was used as the comparison. It is not that simple, though. We cannot say that forest bathing is always 100% better than ordinary walking. Research findings depend on many variables, including the walking environment, pace, duration, participants, and how each study is designed.
What forest bathing asks of you that a regular walk does not
Forest bathing, from the Japanese practice of shinrin-yoku, is not exercise. The goal is to spend unhurried time in a wooded place and pay attention to it. A typical session involves very little distance, often a mile or less over a couple of hours, with frequent stops.
In practice, that means a few specific habits:
- Walking slowly enough that you notice details such as bark texture, the direction of the light, and the sounds of birds or wind.
- Leaving the phone on silent, or off, so that nothing pulls your attention away.
- Stopping to sit or stand still for several minutes at a time.
- Using your senses deliberately: smelling the air, touching leaves, listening for the farthest sound you can hear.
- Not tracking steps, pace, or distance.
A regular walk usually asks for something different. Many people walk to get somewhere, to reach a step count, or to raise their heart rate. They listen to podcasts, answer messages, or think through the day’s problems. None of that is wrong; it simply means the two activities have different goals, and they may have different effects for that reason alone.

What researchers actually measured: cortisol, heart rate, blood pressure, and mood
Studies in this area tend to use a small set of outcomes, and it helps to know what each one can and cannot tell you.
Cortisol. Usually measured in saliva, sometimes in blood or urine, cortisol is a hormone that follows a daily rhythm and rises under stress. It is popular because it is objective, but it also shifts with the time of day, sleep, caffeine, food, and exercise. A single reading before and after a walk can be hard to interpret unless the study controlled for those factors.
Heart rate and heart rate variability. Heart rate usually falls as people relax, and variability measures are used to estimate how much the body’s calming (parasympathetic) system is active. These readings are also affected by physical effort, so a slow forest walk and a brisk street walk start from different baselines.
Blood pressure. Many studies in this area report modest drops after time in a forest, compared with time in an urban setting. Blood pressure responds to posture, movement, and even the act of being measured, so small differences need careful handling.
Mood and self-reported stress. Questionnaires such as mood scales ask people how tense, tired, anxious, or vigorous they feel. These are the most direct measures of how people feel, but participants usually know which condition they are in and may expect the forest to help. Expectation alone can shift a questionnaire score.
Some studies have also looked at rumination, the habit of replaying negative thoughts. One often-cited experiment compared a walk in a natural area with a walk along a busy road and found less rumination after the natural walk. That is a useful finding because it targets a mechanism of everyday stress rather than a single hormone, though it is one study with a limited sample, and you should read the paper itself before leaning on it.
Where the evidence is thin, and how to read a study’s claims with care
The overall direction of the research is encouraging: time in natural settings is generally associated with lower stress measures. The weaker part is the specific claim that forest bathing outperforms an ordinary walk. Several limits apply to a lot of the work.
- Small samples. Many studies involve a few dozen people, sometimes fewer. Small samples produce unstable results, and a difference that shows up in one study may not appear in the next.
- Narrow groups. Some of the early field studies drew mostly on young, healthy adults, often university students. Results may not carry over to older adults, people with health conditions, or people under chronic stress.
- Comparison with a city, not with a walk. A forest-versus-city comparison shows that a forest setting differs from a city setting. It does not show that forest bathing beats walking in a quiet park or on a tree-lined path.
- No blinding. Participants cannot be kept unaware of where they are. People who expect to feel calmer in a forest often report feeling calmer.
- Short-term outcomes. Most measurements are taken right after the activity. Whether the effect lasts for hours, days, or weeks is much less clear.
- Publication patterns. Studies that find an effect are more likely to be published than studies that find nothing, which can make a field look more consistent than it is.
When you read a claim, a few questions help. What was the comparison condition? How many people took part, and who were they? Was the same person tested in both conditions? Were the outcomes measured by instrument or only by questionnaire? And does the article describing the study match what the paper actually reports? Press coverage often turns “associated with lower cortisol in a small sample” into “proven to reduce stress.”
Is it the trees, the pace, or the attention that does the work?
Nobody has a firm answer, but the three candidates can be examined separately.
The trees and the environment. Forests differ from cities in air quality, noise, temperature, light, and the plant-released compounds sometimes called phytoncides. Researchers have proposed that these contribute, though the evidence for any one factor is limited. The quiet alone could account for part of the effect, since noise is a known stressor.
The pace. Slow walking lowers physical exertion, and lower exertion means a lower heart rate. A brisk walk raises it, at least temporarily. If you measure heart rate right after each activity, the slower one will often look calmer for that reason, independent of any trees.
The attention. Directing attention outward to sensory detail, rather than inward to worries, is the basis of mindfulness practice, which has its own body of research on stress. Forest bathing may work partly because it is a form of guided attention that happens to take place outdoors. If so, a mindful walk along a quiet street might deliver part of the benefit.
These factors likely interact, and a study would need several conditions to separate them: slow attentive walking in a forest, slow attentive walking in a city, brisk walking in a forest, and brisk walking in a city. Few studies are built that way. Until more are, the honest summary is that all three probably contribute and that their relative weight is unknown.

A two-week side-by-side test you can run yourself
Your own experience is not a scientific study, but a structured test can tell you more than a vague impression. It works best if you decide the method before you start.
Choose your measures. Pick one or two simple ones. A 1 to 10 rating of how tense you feel, taken just before and about 15 minutes after each walk, is enough. If you own a wearable or a home blood pressure monitor, you can add a reading, taking it the same way each time.
Set up two conditions.
- Your usual walk. Walk the way you normally do, at your normal pace, with whatever you normally listen to.
- A forest-bathing-style walk. Choose a wooded or heavily planted spot. Walk slowly, put the phone on silent, stop several times to look and listen, and spend at least five minutes sitting still.
Match what you can. Keep the duration similar, try to walk at the same time of day, and avoid testing on days with unusual events. If a wooded place is far away, use the nearest green space you can reach and note that you did.
Alternate across the two weeks. Do each condition about three or four times, alternating them rather than doing all of one first. This spreads out the effect of weather, workload, and sleep.
Add a control if you can. Once or twice, take your usual walk slowly and without a phone, but in your normal surroundings. If you feel as calm after that as after the forest walk, the pace or attention may be doing much of the work. If the forest still feels distinctly better, the setting may matter more for you.
Review the notes at the end. Compare average before-and-after changes for each condition, and also look at which walks you looked forward to. With so few data points, treat the result as a personal guide, not as proof.
Gear that makes either practice easier, with a note on affiliate links
Neither practice requires equipment, and the test above can be done in ordinary clothes. A few items can make longer or slower outings more comfortable:
- Comfortable, broken-in footwear with good grip, since forest paths can be uneven or wet. Forest paths can be uneven, muddy, or slippery, so choose footwear that feels comfortable and provides enough traction. You don’t necessarily need expensive hiking boots; a comfortable pair of walking or trail shoes (Ad) may be all you need.
- A lightweight seat pad or small folding stool for the stationary part of a forest-bathing session (Ad)
- A water bottle and a small daypack so you are not cutting a slow walk short because of thirst.
- A rain shell so that weather does not decide your schedule.
- A simple notebook and pen to record your ratings, which avoids reaching for your phone.
This site participates in affiliate programmes, including the Amazon Associates programme. If you purchase through certain links in this article, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. I only include products that may be useful to readers, and you don’t need to buy anything to enjoy either practice.
Have you noticed a difference in how you feel after a slow, attentive woodland walk versus your usual brisk one, and what did you notice?
Final Thoughts: Choose the Walk That Helps You Feel Better
So, is forest bathing better than ordinary walking? Not necessarily. Both can be good ways to get moving, spend time outdoors, and take a break from everyday stress.
Forest bathing encourages us to slow down, notice the sounds, smells, and details around us, and be more present in nature. A regular walk can offer many of the same benefits, especially when we choose a green and peaceful route.
You don’t have to follow a special routine or buy anything to enjoy these benefits. Start with a walk, take your time, and see how you feel afterwards. Perhaps you will discover that slowing down and paying more attention to nature makes a difference.
The best choice is the one you enjoy and can make part of your everyday life. After all, the goal isn’t to turn walking into another task on your to-do list. It is to give yourself a little time to breathe, relax, and enjoy the world around you.
Thank you! Until next time!
Linda Mo
Founder and Owner of How To Reduce Stress Naturally
